The Most Frequently Made Mistake in Case Study Interviews (90% of Candidates Do It!)

Let me tell you with a live example:

The Business Case

  • A candidate was given a business case:

    “A tractor manufacturing company was losing sales every quarter. The challenge? Identify the root cause and recommend a solution.”

The Common Mistake

  • The Common Mistake

    The candidate immediately jumped to solutions:
    “Maybe the pricing is too high? Maybe competitors are better?”

    And that is the most frequently made mistake in case study interviews!

    Do not— I repeat, do not—solve a problem without understanding the problem and structuring your approach (using any framework or first principles).

What the Candidate Should Have Done:

  • 1️⃣ Clarify the Problem

    • Ensure that you’ve correctly understood the problem before jumping to conclusions.
    • Ask questions like: Is the issue company-specific or an industry-wide trend?

    2️⃣ Define the Core Issue

    • Is it a product problem, a market shift, or operational inefficiency?
    • Narrow down the root cause.

    3️⃣ Use a Structured Framework

    • Apply the Four Ps (Product, Price, Place, Promotion) to analyze different angles.
    • Alternatively, use a first-principle-based structure to break down the issue.

    4️⃣ Deep Dive into Insights

    • The real issue? It wasn’t pricing or product quality.
    • The company’s competitors were running village-level trade fairs, offering live demos and financing options—something this company wasn’t doing.

    5️⃣ Recommend Actionable Solutions

    • Suggest:
      • On-ground marketing campaigns
      • Trade fair participation
      • Financial partnerships to regain market share

The Result?

A logical, data-driven response that would impress the recruiters.

💡 Lesson:

“Never rush to conclusions. Understand the problem, structure your analysis, and recommend based on data.”

Bottom Line:

The best professionals aren’t the ones who know all the answers—they’re the ones who ask the right questions.

Get More Insights

QUICK LINKS

POLICIES

CONTACT

2024 GoCrackIt – All Rights Reserved